Friday, 9 September 2011

Book Review | Dead Water by Simon Ings

Buy this book from

Off the coast of Sri Lanka, a tramp steamer is seized by pirates. The captain has his wife and son aboard and knows that their survival depends on giving the pirates exactly what they want. But what can they possibly want with his worn-out ship and its cargo of junk?

On the island of Bali a tsunami washes up a rusting container. Inside, the mummified remains of a shipping magnate missing for 30 years and a hand-written journal of his last days locked within his aluminum tomb.

Through the dusty industrial towns of India's Great Trunk Road, a disgraced female detective tracks a criminal syndicate. Her life has been ruined, but she will have her revenge.

In a backstreet Mayfair office, an automated distress signal is picked up on a private satellite network. A ship is missing. A Dead Water ship. Dead Water is the key to everything. A code name for a covert operation initiated during World War Two. But why is it unravelling now, and what will the consequences be?

***

You can get the measure of most books within a chapter or two, as a rule. Sometimes a sentence is all it takes; a single sentence, or perhaps a paragraph, and you have a general sense of what's to come, what to expect, whether or not it's in your interests (given your interests) to push on.

Of course equally - though a lot less often - texts can obfuscate their intent... veil those things that they are essentially about in such secrets and half-truths and outright lies as to leave the reader reeling; uncertain as to the narrative import of this character or that plot thread, and grasping desperately at whatsoever happens to come their way, whether it is meaningful or otherwise.

Perhaps half of Simon Ings' seventh novel, Dead Water, had come and gone before I had the slightest clue what in the world was actually going on. Just for starters, there was an airship in the Arctic and some baffling political business in the Persian Gulf -- a government-sponsored coup, I gathered. There followed an awful flood in Uttar Pradesh, a tragic rail crash and, intertwined with it, the creation of a Djinn from twins. Finally in the first of Dead Water's five parts, we meet a beat cop on the trail of her mother's murderer.

I say finally. In fact there's nothing in the least conclusive about our introduction to poor, misbegotten Roopa Vish - nor Eric Moyse, polar explorer come shipping magnate, counter-intelligence officer David Brooks, or little Rishi Ansari from the rice paddies - though she is, as it transpires, one of the myriad protagonists of this generation-spanning mystery meets thriller. As are the others, all of whom we meet in such quick succession as to seem indistinct; some of whom don't pop up again for hundreds more pages; none of whom we can truly know till the truth behind Dead Water is revealed.

And what's that? Well... so far as I can tell, and without giving anything away - perfectly par for the course, then - it's a book about boxes, of a sort. "Boxes and boxes and boxes within boxes: this story has swallowed the earth." (p.174) 

Dead Water is a deeply difficult text to get one's head around -- and by design, I don't doubt, for Ings seems an assiduously intelligent author: dynamic and deliberate, daring and often dazzling. This is never more in evidence than during the catastrophic accident aforementioned, wherein "the Purushottam Express collides with the stalled Kalindi service just outside Firozobad, causing the second-worst rail crash in Indian history" (p.49) and transforming two of its youngest victims into omniscient spirits which in a sense haunt every narrative thereafter.

And what of it?

Ings depicts this pivotal moment in a virtuoso bubble of what I can only describe as bullet-time; breaking down the infinitesimal beats of the collision - a real historical tragedy - with such painful precision as to convey in both the micro and the macro the way the world must seem to stop, to grind to a halt, at such abject horror. Thus the reader feels each and every excruciating snap and buck and break as Abhik and Kaneer come into their strange power, and hundreds die around them, including them.

But though "the boys will spin this story out for as long as they can, they're learning fast, they're getting good at this [...] narrative logic demands that what goes up must come down," (p.42) and so indeed it does, eventually. Sort of. There is, at least, a moment when Dead Water starts to come together; or rather than a single moment of revelation, a point at which its many, many threads - no more than an accumulation of seemingly unrelated events before - are at last entangled. And if this entanglement is not necessarily equal to the task of imbuing meaning upon all the abstracted episodes preceding it, then it serves as a frame of reference - a context - for what remains of Dead Water.

And much remains, even now. For "round the bend is a bend and around that bend is another bend. Madness and despair." (p.337) But it passes. And what takes its place... well. I'll never tell.

It speaks to Dead Water's ineffable power, and craft, and cleverness - yes - that I did not for a second think to put it aside to read something more immediately satisfying, for what satisfaction there is in Simon Ings' novel, in the end, is worth its every ounce in gold... or plutonium. It is intelligent but not, I think, at all pretentious. It is complex, certainly, but only as byzantine as (for instance) the gradual back and forth of a box full of boxes across the Indian ocean.

Imagine Alejandro González Iñárritu had written a novel in the mode of his films Babel and Amores Perros, about the inextricable interconnectedness of not merely language or love but the containers almost everything we care about comes in, and returns to. Dead Water is brilliant, in that fashion. But not natural, and never easy.

Then again, is existence ever such a simple thing?

***

Dead Water
by Simon Ings

UK Publication: August 2011, Corvus

Buy this book from

Recommended and Related Reading


Thursday, 8 September 2011

Trailer Trash | Not The Full Full Sequence

Oh my lord it's only the Australian teaser for The Human Centipede 2!

Or is it?

Yes. Yes it is. But truth be told, it isn't much of a trailer. Not even the faint of heart need fear the following:


"Banned in Britain. Cut in the USA. Unleashed in Australia" indeed...

You know, I wouldn't usually waste a post on such rubbish - consider this a freebie! - but I wanted, given the week's discussion, to go on record to say I actually thought The Human Centipede was, for a modern horror film... kind of an incredible piece of work. Surprising and ghastly and relentless yet coherent in a fashion few movies these days dare to be, and supremely effective excepting the awful actors/segments. If more so - as ever - in the beginning than come the inevitable end; because the thought is always more awful, isn't it?

I do not however expect this nonsense to be anything approaching its equal. Not judging from this trailer trash, that is -- which I'm sure it's perfectly unfair of me to do. But fapping to what I can only imagine is repellent body horror? Honestly, this is how you picture your target market?

Well the hell with you, Full Sequence.

Wednesday, 7 September 2011

Film Review | Insidious, dir. James Wan


The one-sheet for Insidious tells you pretty much everything you need to know about the latest in a line of collaborations between writer Leigh Whannell and director James Wan. Creepy kid? Check. Spooky suburban dwelling? Yep. The suggestion of some sort of supernatural evil?

No?

I'm only pulling your legs: but of course there's the suggestion of some sort of supernatural evil!

Insidious is, first and foremost, a movie "from the makers of Paranormal Activity and SAW," so count among its guiding forces the pair aforementioned, in their usual roles, and found footage aficionado Oren Peli, whose exact involvement in Insidious is impossible to gauge. On board as one of three producers (not to mention an array of co-producers, executive producers, and one lonesome line producer), Peli's fingerprints are all over Insidious, smudged though they are; and in any event, I would not swear that he put them there.


Actually, I would not swear that I particularly care whether we have Peli's involvement in Insidious to thank for, for instance, its basic premise - which is to say the haunting of a person rather than a house - or the foreboding creaks and rumbles which are in the first half of the film the primary source of scares, because Paranormal Activity, if you can cast your minds back to a time two whole Halloweens ago, wasn't exactly an original film in itself. The Blair Witch Project meets Poltergeist was and still is, I think, appropriate shorthand for a film which more than anything else demonstrated the cinema-going public's dissatisfaction with SAW VI. Paranormal Activity was ingeniously executed, technically speaking, and narratively surprisingly strong... but no, not at all new, or even particularly innovative.

Nor is Insidious. It, too, is an example of craft over art, and cleverness before invention; of a practiced, indeed accomplished eye where one might wish for vision.

You mustn't mistake me: I had a great time with at least half of Insidious -- and the rest was tolerable enough, if utterly at odds with itself. You should absolutely see this movie. But whatever you do, don't see it expecting anything you haven't seen before.


Insidious is the very definition of a film of two halves. The first part - thankfully the more substantial part - is basically Paranormal Activity without the found footage gimmick. Renai and Josh Lambert are just settling into a nice new place with their three children, Dalton, Foster and a nameless baby; but never mind the latter two. You see, early on, Dalton - that's the creepy kid on the one-sheet - ends up in an inexplicable coma. The lovely Rose Byrne's Renai takes to caring for Dalton full-time, while Josh (Watchmen's Patrick Wilson) shirks his share of the burden by working late a lot. But as he snoozes over tests and essays, Renai becomes increasingly convinced that an uninvited guest has taken residence at the Lambert ranch. Someone - or (gasp!) something - which means her and hers harm. 

It's all so very familiar that you may wonder if you haven't somehow seen this film before. But no, you haven't -- I mean, unless you have. Anyway, never mind the narrative; it's nothing to write home about. Not even to your great-aunt, and she hasn't seen a film since The Exorcist scared her half to death back in the silly 70s. What works in the first half of Insidious - and I should say it works tremendously well - is the unbearable sense of tension wrought from Wan's suggestion of an unseen but ever-present threat. The director takes no time at all to establish this excruciating atmosphere, and finds ample assistance in composer Joseph Bishara, whose lovingly throwback score - though overbearing by modern standards - does as much to dictate exactly where on our chairs we should sit as Wan.


Had Insidious simply sustained this state of affairs for the duration, I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it. However, in its second phase, Insidious takes... we'll call it an odd turn, ending up somewhere between Dead Silence - the delightfully daft puppet horror Wan and Whannell last collaborated on - and The Frighteners; both of which films I'll be the first to admit adoring. But spliced onto an hour approaching the exquisite in its implication of some unspeakable evil lurking just off-camera? Uh...

So it is that Insidious ends a very different film than it begins, with Lipstick-Face Demon, Long Haired Fiend and Doll Girls #1 and #2 (I kid you not) prancing about in "the further" like painted bloody ponies while a man who's been beside the point for the duration stumbles about shadowy, pseudo-Silent Hill sets dodging monsters because he's secretly a total monster-dodger. He is, you hear? Poor Rose Byrne, who holds the rest of film on her heroin-chic shoulders, doesn't even get a look-in.

Oh: there's a twist, too. And it's terrible.

Still, I had my fun with Insidious. I just wish the filmmakers had had perhaps a little less...

Monday, 5 September 2011

But I Digress | The End of Horror

You just can't win with horror, can you?

Over on The Hat Rack the other day, brave Ser Nathaniel of House Katz reviewed The Ritual by Adam Nevill. So what if it came out six months or so ago? Intelligent criticism is always timely, and Nate's an incredibly intelligent critic; of the sort that makes me anxious about my own bloggery bumbling, in fact.


Anyway, in his typically incisive write-up of The Ritual, he of the Hats found much about the last act of Nevill's newest novel to object to -- as I did in my review for The Speculative Scotsman, way back when. Which criticism led to the following comment, from yours truly: 

I'm coming around to thinking that you really can't win with horror along these lines. Either the author rationalises the creepy weird away, which invariably results in disappointment, or he (or she) cuts the narrative short with a dream or a hanging thread and an invitation extended to one's imagination - as Caitlin R. Kiernan has a habit of doing - and that often rankles, too...

I had no answers to the question I posed then, nor do I now, but the more horror I read - and I've always read a lot of horror - the more this seems to me a real problem... this catch-22 of sorts whereby you either give people the answers they seek, and in doing so undermine the unknowableness at the backbone of the vast majority of horror fiction, or else you refuse to explain the inexplicable, and risk the wrath of readers accustomed to neat little bows on all their stories.

In reply to my comment, Nathaniel had this to say:

I agree that there is a huge problem with endings in horror. Of course, one method's the obvious one - just letting the inevitably triumphing evil actually, you know, triumph. Ligotti, for instance, does that, and I know I would've loved The Ritual if, at the end of those two hundred pages, evil did triumph...

But I'll admit that I'm not everyone, and that most people would no doubt hate that kind of ending in a novel. I can think of one or two horror novels that did end in a satisfactory manner - George R. R. Martin's Fevre Dream, for instance - but I can't think of any of the survivalist, great outdoors type that this is, save for The Terror, where I still felt the ending was by far the weakest part. Perhaps the subgenre can only really work in the short story form, where a darker outcome's okay. That'd be a pity, though, as these books do seem to start so well... 

Don't they, though?

I mean, I can hardly begin to tell you how deeply I adore The Terror by Dan Simmons, for instance - if you ask me it's his best book by an Arctic mile, better even than Hyperion - yet Nathaniel's not wrong: in the final summation, even it fell flat. But how could it have ended any other way? I've read The Terror twice, and I haven't the faintest foggiest.

What disturbs me most about all this is that I feel like I've actually come to expect unsatisfactory endings from the horror fiction I read. Going in, I'm already waiting for it all to go wrong... and that can't be right, can it?

So how do you like yours?

Your horror, I mean. Simple, or subtle? Long, or short? Explained down to the last loose end, or left utterly inexplicable?

Is there any way to wrap up long-form horror fiction in a way that satisfies all comers, do you think? Or is it a genre inescapably burdened by the differing expectations of differing readers?

Or am I just mooning at the moon here?

Sunday, 4 September 2011

Books Received | The BoSS for 04/09/11

You know, after the double-dip last weekend, I'd really like to think I was all caught up in terms of books received. Turns out... not so much.

Among the newish releases in The BoSS this week, then: the run of books no doubt inspired by the success of Scott Lynch's series continues apace... a year on from Guardians of Paradise, Jaine Fenn returns, and I've still no clue what to make of her work... there are ninjas -- bloody ninjas at that... a classic fantasy kingdom I've been keeping seekrits about... and oh my God, there are beasts in your bed!

Time to change the sheets, I expect. :/

In fact, how about you guys read about some nearly-new books while I take care of that?

***

Bedbugs
by Ben H. Winters

Vital Statistics
Published in the UK
on 06/09/11
by Quirk

Review Priority
4 (Pretty Bloody Likely)


The Blurb: Alex and Susan Wendt are the perfect couple in search of the perfect Brooklyn brownstone -- and the house at 56 Cranberry Street is too good to pass up. Sure, the landlady seems a little eccentric. And the creepy handyman drops too many strange remarks about the previous tenants. But the sidewalk is lined with trees and there's a beautiful playground just down the block, where their 3-year-old daughter Emma can play.

Many chapters of slow-building dread and paranoia will ensue -- think of this as Rosemary's Bedbugs. Alex loves their new home but Susan is less enthusiastic; something about the new place just doesn't feel right, and she's having trouble sleeping. In the mornings, Susan awakens to find drops of blood on her pillowcase -and soon her wrists are speckled with bites. She immediately suspects bedbugs but she and Alex and the landlady search the apartment without uncovering a single creature. Even stranger, Alex doesn't have any bites on his body. You're just experiencing some kind of psychosomatic reaction, he suggests. I've never seen any bugs. Exterminators search the apartment and find nothing. But Susan is convinced she's right: she's seen the bedbugs, crawling over her body, feasting on her flesh, and swarming in incredibly vivid nightmares.

As her fear and paranoid build to a fever pitch, the story arrives at its horrific conclusion, in which all of the book's many mysteries are revealed. Can Susan contain the bedbugs before they destroy her family? Bedbugs may be the first novel that appeals to both horror/Comic Con fans as well as suburban soccer mums -- and it's a great gift for anyone who's ever battled bedbugs in real life. Sleep tight!

My Thoughts: So the blurb for Bedbugs is... a bit much, shall we say, but I'm actually pretty darned intrigued to read this one. I've only my recent experiences with Quirk's books to go on here, of course - namely the wonders of Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children and the witty words of Geek Wisdom - but I very much admire what I've seen of their slate to date, and the stage is certainly set for some skin-crawling, stomach-churning fun.


I remain ever the optimist! :)


Den of Thieves
by David Chandler


Vital Statistics
Published in the UK
on 07/06/11
by Voyager

Review Priority
2 (It Could Happen)

The Blurb: Enter a world of darkness and danger, honour, daring and destiny in David Chandler’s magnificent epic trilogy: The Ancient Blades. 

Croy is a knight errant, and bearer of an ancient blade with a powerful destiny. He's also kind of, well, dim. He believes in honour. He believes that people are fundamentally good, and will do the right thing if you give them a chance.

Unfortunately, Croy lives in the city of Ness. A thriving medieval city of fifty thousand people, none of whom are fundamentally even decent, and who will gleefully stab you in the back. If you give them a chance.

Ness is also the home to Malden. Malden is a thief. He lives by his wits, disarming cunning traps, sneaking past sleeping guards, and running away very fast whenever people are trying to kill him. Which is often. One time Malden stole a crown. And then he had to steal it back to avoid a civil war. Croy got the credit, of course, because he's a noble knight. Another time the two of them went into the tomb of an ancient warrior race, and Croy accidentally started a barbarian invasion. Guess who had to clean that up?

They probably wouldn't be friends at all if it wasn't for Cythera. Cythera is a witch. A mostly-good witch. And despite herself she can't stop thieves and knights falling in love with her... at the same time.

My Thoughts: Actually, scratch that thing about optimism from the Bedbugs bit.

Really, there's been rather a lot of this sort of thing this year. You know, Gentlemen Bastard-esque fare, presumably to fill the gap which The Republic of Thieves has left after its many and various delays.

Not that that's reason enough for me to be down on Den of Thieves. However, Fantasy Book Critic's Robert Thompson did not approve of book one of The Ancient Blades trilogy, and unless I hear of another, more positive perspective on Den of Thieves sometime soon, I expect I'll be giving this one a miss.


But hey, as ever: it could happen!


Blood Ninja
by Nick Lake

Vital Statistics
Published in the UK
on 01/09/10
by Corvus

Review Priority
3 (We'll See)

The Blurb: Taro is a boy from a coastal village in rural Japan, fated to become a fisherman like his father. But in just one night, Taro's world is turned upside down - and his destiny is changed forever. Skilled in the art of silent and deadly combat, ninjas are the agents of powerful nobles who rule sixteenth-century Japan. So why did a group of these highly trained assassins creep into a peasant's hut and kill Taro's father? And why did one ninja rescue Taro from their clutches, saving his life at enormous cost?

Now on the run with this mysterious saviour and his best friend Hiro, Taro is determined to learn the way of the ninja to avenge his father's death. But if they are to complete their perilous journey, Taro must first evade the wrath of the warring Lords, decipher an ancient curse, resist forbidden love - and come to terms with the blood-soaked secrets of a life lived in moonlight.

My Thoughts: Again, not my usual fare, but I stand in awe of that cover design, and as Conn Iggulden says, Blood Ninja is "a fast-paced, gripping book, with ninjas. It's all I ask for, really."

I could perhaps ask a little more, but whatever. This first Blood Ninja book sounds like fun, Nick Lake seems to have established a solid reputation between this and the other work he does, and with a review copy of the second in the series in my stack now too, I'd best get to Blood Ninja while the getting's good if I hope to get to it at all.

Which yes, I do.


Bringer of Light
by Jaine Fenn


Vital Statistics
Published in the UK
on 18/08/11
by Gollancz

Review Priority
3 (It Could Happen)

The Blurb: Jarek Reen is trying to save a lost world. He discovered the primitive theocracy of Serenein by accident, and now he wants it to take its place in human-space. To do this he needs a shiftspace beacon -- without it, there is no way to find the planet again. The beacons were made by the Sidhe, the race that originally gave humanity access to the stars -- and dominated human-space for millennia, before a coalition of human rebels and Sidhe males brought the evil Sidhe females down.

Most people think the Sidhe are long dead, but Jarek knows better: a renegade female Sidhe is one of his companions, and a male Sidhe gave her and her lover the special powers that made them Angels, very unusual trained assassins. Jarek's only hope is to find Aleph, the hidden system where the last Sidhe males are rumoured to live. But even if he can persuade these eccentric, introspective beings to put aside their interminable internal squabbles, he still has to persuade Serenein that joining the rest of humankind is a good thing... for the price of progress is likely to be high. Can he stop it turning into tragedy?

My Thoughts: Wait, what? Again? Already? 

Well I suppose it's been a year; I shouldn't really be so surprised. But it feels like only yesterday I was intending to get to Guardians of Paradise, and yet, and yet... well, obviously I never did.

Book one gets a good rep on Amazon at least, and though I don't remember it attracting a great deal of attention around the blogosphere, I remain intrigued. Sounds a little Kay Kenyon-esque, and I did dig The Entire and the Rose.

I'm conflicted, folks, so help me out: should I give this series a shot, do you think?


The Illustrated Gormenghast
by Mervyn Peake

Vital Statistics
Published in the UK
on 23/06/11
by Vintage Classics

Review Priority
5 (A Sure Thing)

The Blurb: Enter the world of Gormenghast. The vast crumbling castle to which the seventy-seventh Earl, Titus Groan, is Lord and heir. Titus is expected to rule this Gothic labyrinth of turrets and dungeons, cloisters and corridors as well as the eccentric and wayward subject. Things are changing in the castle and Titus must contend with a kingdom about to implode beneath the weight of centuries of intrigue, treachery, manipulation and murder.

My Thoughts: Last for this week, last but not least - no, very far from least indeed - this beautiful new edition of the Gormenghast trilogy as was, released to accompany Titus Awakes, which Peake's widow put together after the author's passing, has roundly replaced my battered old second-hand editions of the three original novels. Profusely illustrated and with an all-new introduction by TSS favourite Monsieur Mieville, I expect I'll be referring to it rather a lot over the weeks and months to come.


I just can't tell you how or why yet. But know that there is something to know.


I'm not even sorry to be such a tease! :)


But do be sure to stay tuned for some very exciting Gormenghast-related news.

***

On which cruel and unusual note, that's it for this week in books received, boys and girls. The BoSS will be back again next Sunday, as usual -- by which point I expect I may be able to tell you all a little more about... things.

Meantime, please do chime in as regards the Jaine Fenn question, and while you're at it, if you want to wax lyrical about something you've been reading of late, consider the floor open all week long.

Friday, 2 September 2011

Book Review | Wither by Lauren DeStefano

Buy this book from

What if you knew exactly when you would die?

Thanks to modern science, every human being has become a ticking genetic time bomb – males only live to age twenty-five and females only live to age twenty. In this bleak landscape, young girls are kidnapped and forced into polygamous marriages to keep the population from dying out.

When sixteen-year-old Rhine Ellery is taken by the Gatherers to become a bride, she enters a world of wealth and privilege. Despite her husband Linden’s genuine love for her, and a tenuous trust among her sister wives, Rhine has one purpose: to escape – to find her twin brother and go home.

But Rhine has more to contend with than losing her freedom. Linden’s eccentric father is bent on finding an antidote to the genetic virus that is getting closer to taking his son, even if it means collecting corpses in order to test his experiments. With the help of Gabriel, a servant she trusts, Rhine attempts to break free, in the limited time she has left.

***

Another day, another dystopia.

Not that I'm complaining! The end of the world and I are practically bosom buddies, we spend so much time in one another's company. And for my money, all apocalypses are equal... except some are of course more equal than others. Wither by Lauren DeStefano, the first book in The Chemical Garden trilogy, is one of those - and better than most.

Needless to say, the future in Wither is neither bright, nor particularly Orange. Man, ever the innovator, has in one fell swoop laid a terrible genetic plague upon the entire human race, such that men and women each have a strict Best Before Date: come hell or high water, all men die at age 25, while women, to a one, can only count on 20 years. In this time and this place:

It has become a form of escapism to visit a world in which people live a long time. What was once real and natural has become a fantasy. "There are lots of love stories here," she says. "They either end happily or everyone dies." She laughs, but it sounds more like a sob. "What is is there, right?" (p.86)

Some scientists still strive to undo what horrors their predecessors long since wrought upon our DNA (presumably by accident... though I have my suspicions) but middle America at least has made a go of this new status quo, instituting a system whereby men may take multiple wives - by force if necessary - to make multiple babies with, in order, of course, that the species survive until a cure is discovered.

Rhine Ellery is one such unwilling bride. Stolen away from the meager existence she shared with her brother, Rowan, to become one of Linden Ashby's three new wives - replacements for Rose, the love of Linden's life - Rhine does not, unlike her sister wives Jenna and Cecily, go quietly into the great good night of this life of privileged imprisonment. "My sunrises may be limited," she swears, "but I will not view all the rest of mine as Linden Ashby's wife." (p.57)

So it is that Rhine vows to plan and execute a daring escape from the grounds she has been sentenced to. Her best shot at freedom, she reasons, is by earning the trust of her captors: her new husband first and foremost among them. So she'll be a good girl, to a point... and then, when Linden least expects it, she'll run back to Rowan.

Yet "not everything in Linden Ashby's world is as it seems." (p.82) Not even Linden Ashby, for that matter, and in the time Rhine spends on his estate, she finds herself pulled towards two poles, worlds apart: a kind and generous house-servant called Gabriel, who brings Rhine sweets in secret, and also, to a certain extent, Linden himself, who proves a mournful and surprisingly understanding young gentleman.

So there we have it. Linden and Gabriel: our Peeta and Gale for the duration. Which is not to rip Wither a new one; in fact DeStefano's self-assured debut is one of the first dystopian YA fantasies I've read since The Hunger Games whose marketing materials have not drawn such predictable parallels. Instead, the publicity stuffs have suggested Wither has more in common with The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood -- and if you squint a bit... sure, the lineage is there.

But since comparisons have been invited, let me suggest a more apposite one, and say that the first act of The Chemical Garden is more like Logan's Run by way of Big Love with, yes, a whiff of The Hunger Games about it. We would, however, do well to remember that about Suzanne Collins' sensational trilogy too there were whiffs of innumerable other things.

All of which said, Linden and Gabriel are rather carbon copies of Peeta and Gale, from their class-oriented characteristics on down to the dynamic between each of them and Rhine. Nor is Rhine herself a particularly sympathetic or interesting protagonist - she's all a muddle about pretty much everything, and for no good reason (except in service of the narrative as DeStefano sees it) she obfuscates certain essential details about her situation. Nevertheless, given her unfortunate situation, you'd have to be hard of heart indeed to root against her in any way, shape or form.

In terms of character, then, Wither is a trifle disappointing. The world, too, seems something of a non-starter: though in this case only because the reader sees so little of it, since the escape attempt mooted in every synopsis of DeStefano's debut I've seen takes - let me tell you - a long, long while to get off the ground.

But I wouldn't have had it any other way. Moreover, I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Wither to anyone with an interest in your friend and mine, the end of the world as we know it. And that's as much of a surprise to me as I imagine it will be to you, given all I've asserted about this book's shortcomings. But there's a reasonably simple reason for that: namely, the atmosphere. The tension inherent in the premise is terrific, and so thickly layered you'd have difficulty slicing it with a saw, far less the knife usually used for such purposes; hanging always in the air, however convivial it sometimes seems, is the threat of one awful abuse or another, and Wither, though it remains YA-friendly throughout, goes to some fair dark places.

Wither is a chilling, thrilling first novel, tense and intelligent, focused rather than ranging in the mode of so many other dystopias, and if its characters are as yet somewhat simplistic, and its world unfortunately underdeveloped thus far, take heart: there are two more volumes of The Chemical Garden to come, and I would wager Lauren DeStefano has a few more tricks up her sleeve. I'll be looking forward to hearing all about them in Fever, next year.

***

Wither
by Lauren DeStefano

UK Publication: August 2011, Harper Voyager
US Publication: March 2011, Simon & Schuster

Buy this book from

Recommended and Related Reading